When The Witcher Season 4 debuts on October 30, audiences will be greeted by one of the boldest changes the show has attempted: the recasting of its central figure. Henry Cavill’s Geralt set a tone brooding, rugged, and silently dangerous, and fans invested deeply in his interpretation. Now, Liam Hemsworth steps into this shadow, tasked with making the role his own while carrying forward the weighty legacy of three seasons.

What Works

Fresh energy: Hemsworth brings a slightly different cadence and charisma. His Geralt feels more open emotionally (less stony-faced), which allows for new depths in relationships with Ciri and Yennefer.

Supporting cast continuity: Familiar faces,  the sorceresses, the elves, and the political intrigues ground the show. Their chemistry, long built, helps buffer the shock of change.

Bolder narrative arcs: The writing leans into riskier storylines, exploring new corners of the Continent and introducing morally grey dilemmas with greater urgency.

Visual flair and action: The show retains its trademark high production values, visceral monster fights, sweeping landscapes, and moody cinematography, ensuring the spectacle is still there.

What’s Challenging

Comparisons are inevitable: Every move Hemsworth makes will be scrutinised against Cavill’s version. Some will pine for the old guard, especially during scenes that “feel like classic Geralt.”

Tonal balancing act: Hemsworth’s more expressive Geralt can sometimes feel at odds with the world’s grim darkness; striking the right balance is tricky.

Character transition friction: In early episodes, there are moments where Hemsworth seems “introduced” rather than “continued,” which can pull the viewer out of immersion.

Will It Still Impress?

Yes,  though not flawlessly. For fans who view The Witcher as more than just Cavill’s show, Season 4 offers a chance to reset and expand. Hemsworth may not supplant Cavill in everyone’s heart, but he brings his own strengths. The series’s strengths in world-building, supporting ensemble, and production scale remain intact — those foundations aren’t tied to one actor.

If you go in open-minded, Season 4 can still inspire awe, deliver emotional payoffs, and renew your love for monster-hunts and moral quandaries. It may feel different, and occasionally uneven, but it’s a worthwhile continuation, proof that a strong story world can handle even big changes at its core.